Paul Pelham's Story

 
North Carolina 
 
My name is Veronica Roberts. I am writing on behalf of Paul E. Pelham who is currently incarcerated in Johnston 
Correctional in Smithfield, NC. I know that this organization receives thousands of letters from inmates and their 
families alleging their innocence. Paul is innocent in his act. In this letter I will include a lot of information relating to 
Paul's situation. There will be subtopics to make it easier to understand. The subheading, My Story, is in first person 
and directly from Paul. E. Pelham.
 
My Story - by Paul Pelham
 
On the night of October 5, 2001 at about 10 pm the Brunswick County Sheriffs Department came to my home in 
Winnabow, NC with a search warrant. To my understanding this was not an arrest warrant. 
 
Before this incident, earlier that evening I went into my bedroom to lie down because I was not feeling well. While lying 
down, I fell asleep. I don't know how long I was asleep but I was awakened by two loud bangs, I thought I was 
dreaming. I opened my eyes and closed them back again. Soon after there was another loud noise which was closer than 
the other noises. I jumped up out of the bed and felt for my gun under my bed mattress. The lights were off and it was 
dark in the bedroom. The only bit of light was from the moonlight coming through my dark brown bedroom blinds. 
 
I stood in front of the window and held my arm out in front of me trying to get focused. I quickly skimmed the bedroom 
for any movement. As I was skimming the room a person appeared in front of me, standing over me slightly or about 
my height. This person was less than 2 feet in front of me. Out of fear and being startled, I pulled my arm bock in an 
upward, bent elbow position, with the gun pointing down. I fired the gun and the person fell backwards on to the mattress 
and bounced back up. I fired the gun two more times. I did not wait to see what the other person did. Instead, I 
pivoted toward the exit of the bedroom. 
 
I did not make it out of the bedroom door because I saw something like shiny brass going in a downward motion. Therefore, 
I changed my foot direction and ran into the bathroom, which is located in the bedroom. I pressed my body (back) against 
the wall of the bathroom, which is also a bedroom wall.  My left arm was also touching the wall and I had the gun in my 
left hand. Within a matter of seconds multiple gunshots went through the thin mobile home wall where 1 was positioned. 
I heard the person(s) firing the gun, reload their weapons, and fire more bullets. With all the continual firing, the, bullets 
hit me over seventeen times and hit the wall about 70 times. Because the wall was so thin, the bullets went through, hit 
my body, hit and shattered the mirror, hit the bath room sink (where hot water was spraying all over me), and exited out 
of the back wall of the bathroom, outside of the trailer. I was shot on all parts of my body with the exception of my feet. 
I remember the last bullet going through my mouth. 
 
After the person(s) finished unloading their weapons they stated to me "throw out your weapon and to come out with 
your hands up." I threw my gun in front of the toilet and they shined a flashlight on it. Then I walked out the bathroom into 
the bedroom where they shined their flashlights up and down my body. I had to grab and hold what was remaining of my 
left arm. My arm was literally dangling by a piece of skin/meat. One of them realized that I could not put both of my arms 
up because I was injured so badly. 
 
One of the people then walked up to me face to face, grabbed my by the collar, swung/spun me around and kicked me 
to the floor. Then he stated drag yourself you "muthafuckin' nigger." I complied with fear for my life. I was on my back 
and pushed myself with my feet holding to what was left of my arm, As I was pushing myself, I began to slow down 
and somebody pointed a gun with a flashlight. at me. I thought they were going to shoot me again. Then somebody stated 
again to drag yourself you muthafuckin nigger, you shot my partner. 
 
At that moment I realized they must be the police. I remember thinking and perhaps trying to say it "I didn't know it was 
yall (meaning the police)." I dragged myself until I blacked out. I think I blacked out in the kitchen area but very close to 
the living room. 
 
When I came to activity was going on, but I blacked out again and woke up on the ambulance.  As a result I was shot 
17 times. As a result of the seventeen gunshots that entered into my body, I was placed into the intensive care unit at 
New Hanover Regional Medical Center in Wilmington, NC. My left arm was shot until the point it was literally hanging 
on by a small piece of flesh. A bullet went through the side of my mouth and knocked out 3 or 4 teeth, ripped my tongue 
and part of my gums. I had to have reconstructive gum surgery and have my tongue sewn back together. In addition 
to this, I now have a metal plate and about 14 screws in my left arm. My left arm will never be able to bend in a normal 
way because there is a bullet still in my elbow. It is as if my left arm is nothing but dead weight. If I want my elbow 
normal again I will have to have another surgery and have a metal elbow put in. The bullet shattered and broke the elbow 
bone to the point it will never heal normally. I will also need a tendon transfer surgery in order to have some what 
normal working fingers again. I still have two bullets in my upper chest area which you can feel if you touch my chest. 
The doctors did not remove the bullets because it was too much of a risk and it remains a risk today, especially if the 
bullets decide to move. The possibility of the bullets shifting scares me. Bullet fragments are also throughout my body. It 
is only through the mercy and grace of God I am still live today to tell what happened to me.
 
Paul Pelham's Attorney 
 
Paul's attorney's name for his trial was John Calvin Chandler. Mr. Chandler was a public defender appointed to Paul 
in December of 2001. After the initial meeting with Paul, Mr. Chandler did not meet with Paul until 1-2 months before 
his actual trial date. Mr. Chandler did not want to give Paul his discovery at first. He only allowed him to come to his office 
and read fifty pages at a time. Ms. Roberts called the NC State Bar and reported him for not giving Paul complete access 
to his discovery. After the phone call, Paul was given a complete copy of his discovery to take home.  
 
Mr. Chandler also did not want Paul to have any support during the meetings. Paul asked him a couple of times and 
informed Chandler that he wanted me (Ms. Roberts) present during the meetings. Mr. Chandler at first refused until I 
spoke up and told Chandler that I knew there was some type of form that Paul could sign. He finally allowed Paul to sign 
some type of form that gave Ms, Roberts’s permission to be present at the meetings. 
 
Another thing Mr. Chandler did against Paul was inform him that the judge would not believe his story and the judge 
would add aggravated factors to his maximum sentence when he was found guilty. It is not what he said; it is how he said 
it and how many times he said it to Paul. Chandler had such a pessimistic view, even if he thought he was working in 
Paul's best interest, one would have thought he was working with the state.
 
The state offered Paul a plea bargain for sixteen to twenty years for the charge of attempted murder and they would drop 
the other charges.  Paul did not accept the plea bargain. Instead of supporting his client's decision, Mr. Chandler 
badgered Paul and continued to ask him several times if he wanted to take the plea bargain. He even went to the extreme 
and called Paul at home, and then reminded him that he would be found guilty. He told Paul to say goodbye to his family 
also.  Mr. Chandler did not stop badgering Paul about the plea bargain until I, Ms. Roberts, told him that I would call the 
State Bar on him if he asked Paul to accept the plea bargain again. 
 
Mr. Chandler stated to me "go ahead, I have the number." Instead of calling, I wrote a letter to the North Carolina 
Bar Association. Paul's grievance was dismissed without reason though. 
 
Paul also wanted to have his co-defendant subpoenaed, but his lawyer strongly advised him against that. The 
Co-defendant was in the house during the beginning of the incident and could testify to Paul whereabouts. Again 
instead of supporting his client, Chandler tried to intimidate him by stating that if the co-defendant testified, he would 
testify against Paul for the state, and that Paul was not where he said he was during the beginning of the shooting/incident. 
He even tried to intimidate Paul by stating that another friend of Paul's was going to testify against him in order to get 
his sentenced shortened. None of this ever happened. I am sure there are a few things that have been left out left out about 
this incompetent attorney.
 
The Judge 
 
Judge was over Floyd Ammons Jr. was over Paul trial. He was from Fayetteville, North Carolina. The judge allowed a 
4-day break (including the weekend) because he stated he had a prior engagement to attend. There was no court on 
Friday, October 25, or Monday, October 28, 2003. Paul believes this break could have affected the jury's decision. At 
one point in time during jury deliberation, the jury appeared to be hung. However the judge continued to send them back 
in the jury room and emphasized it was their duty to come back with a verdict(s). 
 
The State's Assistant District Attorney 
 
The DA for the state is Chris Thomas. According to Thomas, Paul's motive for the crime was that Paul was already 
on probation and he knew if he got into any trouble he would spend time in jail. 
 
My Story Continued 
 
I had no motive for shooting anybody. I was on probation but that was not related to this case. It was my first time in 
trouble with the law. I received deferred prosecution which consisted of 75 hours of community service, one year 
probation, and random urine tests. Again I had no motive for shooting anyone. I shot a person, whom I did not know 
was a cop, in fear for my life. I believed someone was trying to endanger my life and I had to protect myself. 
 
Now I have been found guilty of 8 charges which amount to 19 and 1/2 years to 26 years. I am in the appeals 
process currently. My appeals attorney is Mark. D. Montgomery located in Durham, NC. I have filed a law suit from 
prison.  My lawsuit claim has made it through the frivolous review and I have been granted permission to proceed with 
my claim. The United States Eastern District Court of North Carolina, Western Division has ordered North Carolina 
Prison Legal Services to do an in depth investigation and possibly help me find a civil attorney.
 
Conclusion 
 
Thank you for taking the time out to read this letter. It is a horrible thing what the Brunswick County Sheriffs Department 
did to my fiancée. They came up in his home with a warrant that Paul never received. Paul was shot several times and 
still suffers from this incident to this day. The BCSD tried to kill Paul that night and failed. Paul stayed in the hospital for 
about one month. Later, I will mail pictures which will illustrate the beginning to the end of his recovery. It is only through 
the grace and mercy of the Father that Paul is still alive today. 
 
He does have a support system, which is willing to help out in any way we can
. 
Again thank you. 
Peace and Justice, 
Paul Pelham
 
Paul Pelham
#0736521
2465 U.S. 70 West
Smithfield, NC 27577
 
Site Map